I’ve just finished the Write Yourself a Scheme in 48 Hours wikibook, implementing a basic REPL and stdlib for Scheme using Haskell and Parsec. You can browse the code on my GitHub; it’s only some 500 lines.
Having completed it, though, I wouldn’t recommend the book to another beginner
as a means of learning Haskell. The lessons spend too much time dictating code
without providing any background for why it’s being done that way. Despite
claiming to be written for people interested in learning Haskell, the book
mostly assumes familiarity with central concepts such as monads and typeclasses.
I also found that not having a working knowledge of Scheme made for a rather odd
experience, as the lessons never consider questions like, “What’s a dotted
list?”, or “How are
I think the book would benefit tremendously from an introductory chapter that discusses the design of the interpreter at a high level, perhaps broadly introducing some of the more core concepts of Haskell and specifying the basic Scheme syntax that will be implemented. Without such guidance, the novice reader is left to plod on through the book assumingly, running headlong through two unfamiliar languages in a nontrivial problem domain. Much of the reader’s time will be spent scratching their head, squinting hard to glimpse some particle of understanding from a seemingly arbitrary composition of partially-applied higher-order functions pulled from an inscrutable, previously unknown library, then lifted, mapped, and returned within one or sometimes two monadic contexts.
Lest this entry be too defamatory, I should assure you that the book really isn’t so bad and that I’m exaggerating the case for effect. In actual fact, I did learn quite a few things along the way, and the final lesson (of implementing a very small portion of Scheme’s standard library) was rather fun.
Highlights of the book include going from
eval args to REPL in just a few
lines, adding support for variables, functions, and lambdas, and the discussion
foldl when implementing
Where next to continue learnng Haskell? Christopher Allen, the author of the forthcoming book Haskell Programming from First Principles discusses and reviews at length many of the resources available in Functional Education. I’ve also thought about trying to modernize the code I wrote for the Scheme interpreter, possibly updating the wikibook afterwards. At the moment, though, I’m most interested in beginning an LLVM tutorial that implements a toy language named Kaleidoscope. The tutorial is written using OCaml, a language not too unlike Haskell, and translating their implementation seems like a worthwhile exercise.